Pilcher's Shoes - North Webster, Indiana

Doug N.

Best shoe buying experience you will ever have, absolutely huge variety of shoes. They can customize your fit, width, arch, padding. All included for free with purchase. I will not and have not bought shoes anywhere else since I've first went! Great people, great selection, amazing experience.

Michelle R. M.

Drove to this store from Middlebury. Was well worth the drive! Mr. Pilcher and Taylor helped my boyfriend and I get the “right” shoes for our needs. We both got the Brooks Adrenalin GTS 24. Best shoes I have ever had! Thank you so much for such personal attention! Will definitely be back!

Cara C.

My husband and I were visiting North Webster for the day. We decided to see what Pilcher's Shoes was like inside, as we had driven by it for years. We left with two new pairs of sneakers. Bob spent a lot of time making sure we were both properly fitted. If you go in, make sure you have enough money to spend, as you will not want to leave wearing your old pair. Comfortable shoes, caring customer service, and comparable prices to other running shoe stores.
Thanks also for the prayers!

Alivia V.

Totally impressed with staff and inventory! I’ve never felt so confident in picking out a shoe- thank you to Bob and his team who were knowledgeable and knew exactly what I was looking for before I did lol they were awesome! We will definitely be back

Sagan S.

I would give them ten stars if I could! I have driven by Pilcher's literally hundreds of times on my way to work, I've lived in the Barbee area for 15 years and I have just never stopped. The building is a CASTLE!!! Kind of an intimidating structure to walk into, but boy will you feel like a Royalty when you walk out. Get ready to be treated like a Queen or King because Pilcher's customer service is on the next level. I have always had problems with my feet. Like bring you to tears at the end of a night shift kind of feet. Following a few recommendations from friends and family, I decided to just do it! I was going to the Castle for shoes!
From the moment I walked up to the building I was treated as someone special. From the guy seemingly trimming bushes out front to Dawn and her nephew, everyone was incredibly friendly and helpful. Dawn spent a long time fitting my shoes just right for ME. I have never experienced such personal attention while shoe shopping. She NAILED it. I have never felt more comfortable in my shoes. When I first walked in my custom fitted shoes, I could have cried. Finally, a pair of shoes that feel like a part of my foot. I don't know that I've had that feeling before. The shoes may be on the higher price scale, but for one - you just walked into a Castle, two - these are Quality brands that you would pay twice the price for once they are custom fitted. My feet have never felt better.
If you haven't given Pilcher's a try, go treat yourself, your feet will thank you!

Melody D.

I have heard of this store and it's amazing selection for years. I expected a giant shoe collection inside, but it's only the second floor and the only sell Brooks sneakers and some random dress shoes.

The fitting experience is supposed to be great, but mine was not.

I feel bad writing this review, because the man running the store seems nice, but unsure how to get more traffic.

He had three young men just standing around.

The building feels incredibly old and stale. Just unpleasant to be in.

JOSH M.

this is the best place to go for a pr of steel toes you dont want ta know are on ur feet! agreed there should be 10stars for this place hands down amazed at staff and the knowledge of how to fit you comfortably!!! will be going back in 30days to pick up another pr they put back for me that i liked too!!! who does that? this is my new shoe store period.

Tonya S.

Prices are high,my mom went in for a custom shoe fitting because she had a sore toe the guy kept touching her toe I think trying to be funny when she yelled in pain he come looking for me as I was looking for shoes as well and said she was being loud well yes of course she would be because he kept touching her toe! I have been to that store in 20 years. Mom bought a pair of shoes marked $133.99 said he gave her a 10 percent discount she still paid $134. I guess if you need the custom touch I'd probably not go here if travel elsewhere. Just being honest