Clever Bay Sports & Gaming - Evansville, Indiana

Garrett W.

This may be my new favorite card store in town. As a huge fan of both Magic the Gathering and sports in general this place is amazing! The staff were immediately super nice, helpful, and informative. It's clean, brightly lit and has a really cool atmosphere that I would happily bring my kids to.

Pricing was extremely fair and everything had a visible price tag on it. My biggest gripe with other stores is having to look up the price of cards that are on display on my phone. Not only could I get an idea of the price but all the cards were fully visible in the case which is a HUGE plus. The projector playing live college basketball on the wall got me too, honestly if they had a bar I might ask to move in.

All in all this place is really cool with great staff and a welcoming environment for any level of tcg or sports fan. I will absolutely be frequenting this place regularly!

Justin D.

Been breaking with Chris at Clever Bay Sports & Gaming since 2020, and let me tell you – if it wasn’t for being across the country, I’d probably be in that shop way too often. Chris handles his business like a pro; he’s always quick, spot-on with shipping, and keeps things smooth. Seriously, if you’re looking for someone who’ll treat your pulls like gold and ship them without a hitch, this is your guy. Highly recommend Clever Bay and Chris for your sports card and supply needs.

Teeeve

Stopped by here for the first time a couple weeks ago, right away I noticed that all the Pokémon stuff was pretty fairly priced. They had a pretty good selection of what I was looking for, And everyone in there was really nice. I’ll be a frequent customer here.

Dekoda C.

I can say that this place is more than a sports and game shop. They are family. They’ve invited me over multiple times to just come hang out and bring my kids just so they can have fun and hang out in the store. They’re trade-in prices are the best that I have came across Plus, they have been so awesome and to teaching me about cards and teaching my kids about cards and what to look for even if I lived an hour away, I would still drive that just to come see them which I do in fact.! if you’re just starting or wanna learn this is the place to go. They’ve also helped me sell some of my high dollar cards which I sold for three and almost $10,000 so no matter the price or size they will get it done for you.

Adam B.

Chris and Theo are two of the best I know in this hobby. When I go in their store I feel like family more so than a customer. They have an amazing selection, great prices, and treat everyone fairly. Highly recommend this store.

Todd P.

Theo and Chris are awesome dudes. We have been shopping there almost since their opening. My son and I mainly buy Pokemon cards there. I have always been satisfied with our experience. They seem to be looking for ways to better the customer experience (example TCGPlayer store). If I could give more than 5 stars I would.

Michael H.

Absolutely the best place to trade/sell cards. The owners, especially Chris, are great guys who know just about everything there is to know about anything sports related. I recently sold some graded cards and they really helped me out and even gave me a little more cash on some of the cards. They also have a crazy selection of Pokémon, Magic, basketball, baseball, football cards and more. Also tons of memorabilia including signed framed jerseys and helmets, bats, and also autographed mini helmets. As a former frequent customer of The Hobby Den to buy/sell/trade, I will now only be coming to Clever Bay Sports & Gaming from now on; Due to the fact that not only are they the most fair and knowledgeable, but the staff makes you feel like family and will treat you as such. Wish I had known about this place much sooner!!

Matthew F.

This shop from top top bottom is top notch. Are they the best around no do they treat you with respect no matter what you're looking for, knowledge level or price you're looking to spend. I know the owners personally and the entire family. Of you want a cool place to talk cards games or sports and you're in the area hit them up.