Indy Card Exchange - Indianapolis, Indiana

Jeffrey C.

Indy Card Exchange is a gem for sports card enthusiasts! I recently visited and found some amazing NBA cards featuring my childhood heroes like Michael Jordan, Allen Iverson, Kobe Bryant, and Vince Carter. This store brought back so many good memories!
What I love about Indy Card Exchange is that they cater to all collectors, not just those looking for high-end cards. They offer a great selection of low-budget and mid-range cards, making it easier for new collectors to start their hobby. The staff and the owner are incredibly passionate and helpful. They went above and beyond to help me find some Allen Iverson jersey cards within my budget, and I am so grateful for their assistance.
My visit to this store was very pleasant, and I will definitely come back the next time I’m in Indiana. Highly recommend for anyone interested in sports cards!

ibrahim T.

My son ( …and me :)) started his card-collecting journey at Indy Card Exchange, and I can’t thank Andy, his son Quinn, Shane, and Drew enough for their patience and warm welcome. We’re just at the very beginning of this collector’s journey, yet it’s amazing how they treat everyone the same—whether you’re a total beginner like my son (…and myself) or a seasoned collector with years of experience. Their ability to manage expectations and provide thoughtful guidance for every level is unmatched.

The shop has such a welcoming, club-like atmosphere—it feels like you’re part of something special the moment you walk in. Sitting at the iconic Jordan bar, watching others, sharing excitement, and having fun together is such a unique experience. Even the more experienced collectors are incredibly kind and generous, offering tips and helping along the way. My son has claimed his own lucky spot at the bar to tear open packs, which has already become a fun little tradition for us.

What makes it even better is knowing that Indy Card Exchange is a small, family-owned local business. Supporting them isn’t just about cards—it’s about being part of a community that values kindness, passion, and connection. We couldn’t be happier to start this journey with them, and we’re so grateful to have such a gem right here in our city!

Dan B.

I've been here a couple of times with my son to casually sort through some cards and pick out what he likes. The people there are pretty helpful and they don't mind if you loiter a bit in search of the right thing.

One note: if you go on a Saturday, there's a good chance it will be packed.

Jack H.

Indy card exchange is a super-refractor tier card shop. Andy and the rest of the lads are very fair. Very knowledgeable. And have created a fantastic community. A one time visit to buy a gift for a friend 3 years ago, has turned into my favourite hobby.

preezy

By far best card store in Indiana, probably in the Midwest, love the owner and staff… worth taking a day out to check them out, you will not be disappointed at all! Keep up the great work

Taylor H.

I took my 9- and 7-year old sons here for the first time last week. Andy, the owner of the store, introduced himself and gave us a quick rundown of how the shop worked. Andy was very friendly and knowledgeable. It was evident that he started this card shop to rekindle the amazing hobby of sports cards for the current and future generations. There is a huge selection of cards here for every budget.

We signed up for the free kids club. The kids get a special gift every month, for good report cards, and for their birthday months. We will definitely be making regular trips to this card shop. My boys had a great time picking out cards and seeing the memorabilia on the walls. I cannot recommend ICE enough!

luffdziedzic

Seems like a nice place. But my experience was not. came into buy and sell some cards was told one other person was infront of me waited a awhile. Then another customer walked in ploped cards on the table and was delt with first. Dont come in unless you know the owners was the feeling I got. Went to Game Time 7 minutes away. Sold my cards. Bought some more. And had a great experience.

Kaitlyn C.

Favorite card shop in Indy. The staff are always kind and helpful. Prices are fair and the selection is good. They always have women’s sports cards stocked which is hard to find in a shop!